Zinke review is reasonable

Zinke review of Utah National Monument is reasonable

Print Article

I write regarding Ryan Zinke’s recommendation to reduce two national monuments in Utah. I am not well-versed on many of the monuments under review nationwide, but lived and worked in Utah for many years, and feel knowledgeable about the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument.

Grand Staircase-Escalante is a magnificent and beautiful place, and deserves some level of protection. However, at almost 1.9 million acres (roughly the size of Delaware) it is a huge area. Located on BLM lands, even its own land managers concede it’s highly difficult to manage (made even more so given cuts under Bush and Obama administrations).

In the counties the monument occupies, Garfield County is almost 93 percent federally owned, and Kane County, nearly 90 percent. These rural counties face challenges maintaining economic opportunities with large percentages of federal ownership and restriction to land use, and reasonably felt they were put under additional pressures from the monument, which further restricted resource-based opportunities, particularly mining, which could have been permitted on the BLM land.

Tourism jobs have been added, but as many Montanans know, these jobs seldom produce year-round, good-paying or benefit-offering opportunities for families.

In two counties stretched thin, Clinton’s creation of the monument, in his last days of office, under the Antiquities Act, did not thoroughly consider the challenges of these communities to maintain jobs or what size would be sustainable for the long-term management of the monument itself.

It does not seem unreasonable for Zinke to review this monument for possible reduction in size, which could, in effect, better allocate its resources for better management and resource protection, and allow for a better look at these counties’ economic needs.

From my knowledge of this one monument, it seems rational and reasonable that it be reviewed.

—Jessie Walthers

Bigfork

Print Article

Read More Letters to the Editor

County’s response to Hecla matter disappoints

April 24, 2018 at 5:00 am | Western News To the editor: A recent “guest column” by our Lincoln County Commissioners about Hecla Mining and the State of Montana’s attempt to enforce the “bad actor law” in regards to their proposed Montanore...

Comments

Read More

Get rid of State-level ‘greenies’

April 24, 2018 at 5:00 am | Western News To the editor: The Environmental Policy Board is made up of three greenies who do all the dirty work of stopping mining for Earth First and other self-engendered environmental groups. If only our ...

Comments

Read More

More thoughts on the killing of the wolf-hybrid dog

April 13, 2018 at 5:00 am | Western News To the editor: How does one make sense out of a senseless killing? Just saying “No laws were broken” doesn’t make it right. Maybe sharing more details will diminish my outrage level. Eighteen years...

Comments

Read More

Giving away your data

April 13, 2018 at 5:00 am | Western News To the editor: Most data is obtained legally, with your consent. But many times you don’t recognize when you are providing your information. There are many steps you can take to help protect your pr...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 293-4124
311 California Ave.
Libby, MT 59923

©2018 The Western News Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X