Cuts to most vulnerable not justified

Print Article

Montana can do better for its elderly citizens. In fact, the state needs to. Services to our most vulnerable people do not need to be cut to balance the budget. There are other choices and we are urging the Department of Public Health and Human Services to rethink proposed cuts.

Our company, EmpRes Healthcare, celebrated 20 years of service in Montana on May 1, offering skilled nursing services in mostly rural Montana including Shelby, Polson, Hot Springs, Missoula, Livingston, Lewistown, Laurel and most recently, in Billings. We agreed to run the Shelby, Lewistown and Billings facilities when their hospital owners were finding it difficult financially to maintain quality services and were facing potential closure. For Shelby and Lewistown, in addition to the economic impact of losing a major employer, closure would mean that elderly people would have to leave their community and family to get nursing home care.

Every day, the 544 employees of our employee—owned company care for 408 Montanans, 72 percent of whom depend on Medicaid. Our cost of providing care to them averages $36 per day more than the rate Medicaid pays. We operate by shifting the burden to those who pay privately and Medicare. This is not sustainable or fair. The state should pay the fair cost of serving those who rely on Medicaid.

Last year, our eight facilities paid $1,029,781 in bed taxes — which is a direct savings to the state general fund because our taxes are used instead of general fund to support rates to nursing homes. This year, we will pay $1,401,991 in bed taxes because nursing facilities agreed to increase the tax through HB618. We supported HB618 because it took advantage of available federal matching funds and reduced the substantial shortfall in our Medicaid rates. Without the tax and the rate increase it generates we would have to shift more costs to those paying privately and make decisions that could affect the quality of our services.

We are disappointed that Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services is proposing to use part of the increased tax on nursing homes to fill a hole caused by the 3.47 percent cuts the department is making. They have to know that Medicaid providers cannot handle a cut of this size. It’s three times more than the one percent cut proposed by the Legislature!

Without these cuts, funding shortfalls already make it difficult to operate. Increased costs of health insurance, food, medical supplies and equipment — as well as unfunded mandates for electronic health records and new federal regulations, put a strain on nursing home budgets. Providing even basic improvements to residents’ living environments is difficult. Given mandated and fixed costs, should the cuts become a reality, we will have to look at reducing staff hours — not because that’s a good idea, but because labor is the largest variable cost to look to when cuts are made.

Montana can do better. Montana must do better. There are other ways to balance the budget. We are willing to meet with the department to discuss ways we can partner with the state to effect long term savings and efficiencies in the way health care is provided in Montana. Together we can make sure we keep our promises to our most vulnerable neighbors.

Dale L. Patterson is director of government relations at EmpRes Healthcare Management in Vancouver, Washington.

Print Article

Read More Editorial

The American West is burning

September 22, 2017 at 11:55 am | Western News Hurricanes such as Harvey, Irma and Maria are unstoppable. They rip at our coastlines and tear at our hearts. The yellow, orange, red, even purple colors on the Doppler radar and weather maps this ...

Comments

Read More

Cyber attack a wakeup call

September 22, 2017 at 10:53 am | Daily Inter Lake For most of us, the last week in Flathead County has seemed like something out of a movie. The idea that an anonymous hacker or hackers could shut down 19 school districts as well as several priva...

Comments

Read More

Fuel and fire: A case for federal forest management and reforms

September 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Western News For most Montanans, this is not just another fire season. The 2017 season started early and is predicted to continue until a season-ending event such as rain or snow by November. Unfortunately for ...

Comments

Read More

Facts matter when it comes to addressing wildfires

September 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Western News Montana is on fire, we’ve been breathing smoke for months, and it’s human nature to look for someone or something to blame, such as environmentalists or the Forest Service. But the fact is we can’t...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 293-4124
311 California Ave.
Libby, MT 59923

©2017 The Western News Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X